Recently been stumped by this clunk noise when I brake or accelerate, and sometimes going over rough surface. Have checked all the bolts around arm, steering play, and have recently changed the top mount rubber on the O/S front.
I noticed that when I jacked car up and grabbed spring on O/S it seemed to be moving back and forth. I'm not sure if it was just a bit loose because the tension was off it but the other side never done this, nor did my other cav when I checked it's springs.
Decided to take off the strut and have a look. Couldn't really see much that would be a cause for concern but the top rubber mount, while not looking worn, it certainly seemed softer when I pressed it up and down compared to a new one.
So replaced that, however noise it still there, although it seems to be not doing it as severe but hard to tell. For instance if i was approaching stationary traffic I would start to lightly brake (clunk) then brake harder as I approached (clunk) then final press to stop (clunk again) yet sometime hear the noise if the N/S wheel goes over a lump in the road.
The noise does seem to be right in front of me suspecting the top mount. I noticed when I replaced the top mount that the space between the top mount plate and the inner wing is gone but other side has a gap of about 4mm, which is quite large and suspect then that it needs replaced too. I did have this gap before the rebuild work and never had any clunk sounds however.
Looking at the front wheels on O/S the wheel seems to be sitting back a bit, it seems offset in the arch. I don't ever remember this before as that is something I always keep my eye on all my cars. The supsension arms are relatively new, there is no play and the tyres are both exactly the same make and worn the same.
On drivers side I can not really get 3 fingers through the gap but on NS can get 3 in quite easily with a gap left.
This is really baffling me now, nothing is loose, nothing seems worn, apart from top rubber mount on N/S yet I have this wheel out of line and this clunking noise all the time. Any thoughts would be very much appreciated.